Showing posts with label "N" Authors. Show all posts
Showing posts with label "N" Authors. Show all posts

Saturday, May 03, 2008

The Twelfth Window

[lhs_star_rg2.50.gif]Norwood, J.M. 2007. The Twelfth Window.

What can I say about The Twelfth Window? It's an almost-but-not-quite book. The characters were almost. The plot was almost. The setting was almost. It's supposed to be a parable-of-sorts of the Christ story. His life, his death, his resurrection. This kind of thing has been done before--in a way--for example C.S. Lewis and J.R.R. Tolkien are known for their great fantasy fiction. And while not everything each of those has written is allegorical in nature, a good bit of it is. It is easier, in a way, to have a parable or allegory set in an other-world. Narnia. Middle Earth. Set someplace long ago or far away. A place that is so unlike present-day life that it is easier to suspend your disbelief. The setting of The Twelfth Window, on the other hand, is a locale that is Different-Yet-Not-Different-Enough. It's set in the 1980s. It's set in a high school. It features a typical girl, Lisa, who worries about many typical things: her friends, her popularity, having or not having a boyfriend, parental issues, her studies and school work. There are just one or two big differences keeping this from being your normal high school melodramatic realistic fiction. One, Lisa and her family--and a few of her friends--are religiously devout. They attend Temple. Their worship, their spirituality or religion is different. Made to be a stand-in perhaps for the God of the Old Testament, the story is fairly familiar but the names have all been changed. This isn't a bad thing. I'm not saying it is. If Christians can see Christ in Aslan. They might very well learn to see Christ in Atael. The second big difference is what I hinted at earlier. In this particular allegory, this particular story, Christ--Atael--has not come yet. Nor are the people expecting him to come. They don't know quite what the prophecy is that will fill the 12th Stain-glassed window, but they know it hasn't happened yet. Again, this has been down a handful of times before. What would the world be like if Christ came in the Twentieth Century. Yet in most of the other versions, the world is so dramatically different that it would hardly be recognizable to modern readers. It certainly wouldn't feel like the real deal--the 1980s. I can't honestly speak to the authenticity. I wasn't in high school in the 80s. I was in elementary school. i certainly wasn't keeping up with fashion or slang or music. But it feels close or close enough. To say that I had a hard time wrapping my head around the premise that this Christ-figure was a somewhat typical albeit smarter but poorer high school student is an understatement. Michael Joseph, the boy we're supposed to identify with Christ, is poor. He doesn't have a family. He works at a local diner and lives in a relatively dingy place above the diner. He is a kind, compassionate, good. He is forgiving of others' faults. He tries his best to get along with everyone. But he's just as well.He won't let others be bullied or pushed around. He speaks up for those in need. He tutors those who need it. He counsels those who need it. He's your all-around good guy, your saint. Lisa is his girl friend. Yet Lisa is not a saint. As representing the Church, or representing Christ's Beloved, she has to be faithless and doubtful in order to fill the role. The presence of angels and their counterparts might remind readers of some of Frank Peretti's work.

Yet I feel, in a way, this is too ambitious of an undertaking. It might almost work. But it has a long way to go. The writing is jumpy. Jumpy to the point where it loses clarity, loses focus. More often than not, I was left with the feeling, "How did I get here? What happened?" The narrative is a collection of loosely related vignettes or scenes. Often conversations will occur and you're at a loss of how you got there, where you are, where you're going, and why you're there with this person, this character in the first place. While some of this may be intentional, I couldn't help but get the feeling that the author was assuming that just because she understood it that her readers would as well. She might could jump and leap and twist and turn all over the place without getting lost, but I was lost and confused and puzzled. The plot lacked clarity for most of the novel. I wasn't confused on everything, on every little detail. But there were plenty of gaps and holes that kept me from seeing the big picture, the cohesive whole. I'll tell you exactly what it reminded me of. Of listening to one half of a phone conversation. The writing. I'll let you judge for yourself. Most of the time it was good enough--satisfactory enough. Nothing special. Nothing outstanding. Just average. But not awful. Not terrible. But it told more than it showed. And it somewhat-liberally used underlining especially in the second half of the book. There is a reason most authors don't use underlining to get their tone across.

"Reconciling with the one you love is its own spring. The heavy snows of guilt, the ice of blame and the biting winds of vanity all melted away by virtue of the care, the new understanding and the deeper love that Lisa and Michael had and felt for each other. A month and a day after they made up, he gave her a new photo of him to replace the one she had ripped up. The gang was together again even though winter plodded on..." (157)

It does have five--yes, five--five stars on Amazon. (To clarify of the five reviews it does have, all of them are five-star reviews.) And according to the AuthorHouse website, it is a finalist for the ForeWord Book of the Year Award. So it appears I'm in the minority on this one.

© Becky Laney of Becky's Book Reviews

Wednesday, November 29, 2006

Wait for Me

Na, An. 2006. Wait For Me.

An Na’s first novel, A Step From Heaven, was a National Book Award finalist and Michael L. Printz Award winner. Her second novel, Wait For Me, features older protagonists. Mina is the imperfect daughter trying desperately to live up to her mother’s high expectations. Since she can’t meet them naturally--no matter how hard she tries--she has formed the bad habit of lying to her parents, her friends, and to some extent herself. Mina is a complex character torn between finding herself and living authentically and continuing to live the lie of a ‘perfect’ and ‘obedient’ daughter that her mother expects and demands. She is also desperately trying to be there to support her younger sister, Suna, who is hearing impaired. Suna is mistreated (verbally abused) by the mother and has been since childhood when her problems came to light. The father is also pushed around (manipulated) by this domineering, controlling woman. But how long can one live a lie? Wait For Me chronicles the summer before Mina’s senior year in high school as her ‘perfect’ world begins to crumble and be replaced by a truer more authentic one. It is told through both Mina’s and Suna’s voices.

Friday, September 22, 2006

Beast

Napoli, Donna Jo. 2000. Beast.

Donna Jo Napoli’s BEAST is a modern retelling of the classic tale Beauty and the Beast told from the point of view of the Beast. Borrowing details from Charles Lamb’s retelling written in 1811, Napoli begins the story in Persia with a young prince named Orasmyn. After a religious mistake--sacrificing an animal unfit for sacrifice--the young man is cursed by a fairy “pari” and transformed into a lion. Told that only a woman’s love would break the spell, Orasmyn wanders Persia, India, and all the way to France making peace with his new self. Not expecting to ever even meet a young woman face to face--let alone try to woo her--he settles in an abandoned castle until one day...
While readers will always be familiar with traditional fairy tales, new retellings offer great pleasure adding new depth and perspectives to old stories.

Charles Lamb's Beauty and the Beast, 1811
SurLaLune: The Annotated Beauty and the Beast
SurLaLune: Modern Interpretations of Beauty and the Beast
Beauty and The Beast Home
http://www.donnajonapoli.com/

Tuesday, September 12, 2006

Family Legacies

Nelson, Suzanne. 2006. The Sound of Munich.

Siena Bernstein is a seventeen year old girl on a secret mission: while studying abroad a semester in Germany, she wants to find the man responsible for helping her father and grandparents escape East Berlin. Being half-German has never meant much to Siena, after all, her father died when she was a baby. She’s never known his family--or even if his family is still alive. But when her friend urges her to apply to study abroad in the Students Across the Seven Seas program, it’s an opportunity Siena siezes. Now she’s anxious to connect with her German heritage and perhaps learn a little about who her father was, what she doesn’t expect is to come to a new realization of who she is.The Sound of Munich is an entertaining YA novel with a heart. Siena and friends learn much about life, friendship, and perhaps more than they ever wanted about sausage.

Other titles in the series (S.A.S.S.) include

Getting the Boot by Peggy Guthart Strauss (2005)
Pardon my French by Cathy Hapka (2005)
Spain or Shine by Michelle Jellen (2005)
Westminster Abby by Micol Ostow (2005)
Now and Zen by Linda Gerber (2006)
Heart and Salsa by Suzanne Johnson Nelson (2006)

S.A.S.S. series from Penguin Group