Showing posts with label romance reading challenge. Show all posts
Showing posts with label romance reading challenge. Show all posts

Thursday, April 24, 2008

Gone With The Wind


Mitchell, Margaret. 1936. Gone With The Wind.

You can't always get what you want
But if you try sometimes you might find
You get what you need...

--The Rolling Stones

Because I used to love her, but it's all over now...
--The Rolling Stones

Scarlett O'Hara was not beautiful, but men seldom realized it when caught by her charm as the Tarleton twins were. (5)

Thus begins Margaret Mitchell's classic novel Gone With The Wind. Does it surprise you that Scarlett O'Hara "was not beautiful"? Can you conceptualize (fancy word for imagine) a Scarlett O'Hara that isn't beautiful? Try. Really. I bet you can't help but think of the beautiful Vivian Leigh. And that is where I think Hollywood did a huge disservice to the world. I have a love-hate relationship with the movie. I do. The movie has its moments of brilliance. Moments I love. But the movie has little to do with what Margaret Mitchell actually wrote. It got a few of the surface details right, I think, but it makes a mockery of it in places. Mitchell's novel has heart and soul and substance. Actual substance. The movie? Well. It's more stereotypes. Hollywood's version of the South is far from the South portrayed in Mitchell's pages. Especially when it comes to Scarlett and Tara. (But I digress.)

What did Scarlett look like? We're told that "it was an arresting face, pointed of chin, square of jaw. Her eyes were pale green without a touch of hazel, starred with bristly black lashes and slightly tilted at the ends. Above them her thick black brows slanted upward, cutting a startling oblique line in her magnolia-white-skin" (5).

Even if you've never read the book, I would imagine you've got a fairly good notion of what Gone With The Wind is about. At least on the surface. It's the story of the spoiled-rotten Scarlett O'Hara and her quest to win her heart's desire through any means possible. Scarlett is one that doesn't ask if it's wrong or right. She only lives by this question--does it get me one step closer to what I want? If it does--then look out!

Scarlett. Rhett. Ashley. You probably know the basics. A woman wants what she can't have. She wants it until she can have it. The moment she has it. She doesn't want it anymore. Scarlett is in a perpetual state of frustration. The man in her bed doing her bidding is rarely the man in her heart.

The book is about much more than Scarlett and her quest for love, however. It's a love story, I won't deny it. But there is much more than love at stake in the novel. War. Reconstruction. Civilization. Society. Culture. Class. Race. Money. Politics. Survival. It's a novel of contrasts. The Old South vs. The New South. Conformity vs. Individuality. The haves vs. the have-nots. If asked to sum up Gone With The Wind in one word, most would probably say "Love." I'd say gumption. People who have it; people who don't. What do I mean by gumption? Partly spirit. Partly courage. Partly determination. Partly ambition. People with gumption act. They do what they must when they must.

One of my favorite non-love scenes from the book is Scarlett's conversation with Grandma Fontaine. A wonderful, wonderful character by the way. The setting is after Gerald's funeral. Scarlett is pregnant with Frank Kennedy's baby. (Yes, the movie killed Gerald, her father, off too soon.)
"We bow to the inevitable. We’re not wheat, we’re buckwheat! When a storm comes along it flattens ripe wheat because it’s dry and can’t bend with the wind. But ripe buckwheat’s got sap in it and it bends. And when the wind has passed, it springs up almost as straight and strong as before. We aren’t a stiff-necked tribe. We’re mighty limber when a hard wind’s blowing, because we know it pays to be limber. When trouble comes we bow to the inevitable without any mouthing, and we work and we smile and we bide our time. And we play along with lesser folks and we take what we can get from them. And when we’re strong enough, we kick the folks whose necks we’ve climbed over. That, my child, is the secret of the survival.” And after a pause, she added: “I pass it on to you.”

The old lady cackled, as if she were amused by her words, despite the venom in them. She looked as if she expected some comment from Scarlett but the words had made little sense to her and she could think of nothing to say. (709-710)

It's a novel that goes above and beyond the central character of Scarlett. Even if you hate Scarlett, I'd imagine you'd find some character to love. Be it Melanie. Rhett. Mammy. Uncle Peter. Grandma Fontaine. How could you not? There are so many characters, so many individual stories. Stories of triumph. Stories of loss. Stories of hope. Stories of disappointment. Stories of survival. Stories of failure. There is depth and meaning that the movie doesn't even try to accommodate. Depth and meaning that even diehard fans can't help but learn something new with each rereading.

I don't want anyone to think I'm glossing over some of the book's issues. You'd have to be a fool to not realize that Gone With The Wind has more than a little potential to be racially offensive. It could be seen as abrasive even. It uses these words interchangeably: n-word, darkie(s), slaves, and Negroes. A good many of uses of the n-word come from slaves/servants conversing with one another. But there are many that aren't. And regardless of who is speaking it in the novel, the context of the novel, you can't escape the fact that it is a white author. There are phrases, there are scenes, that you can't deny are racist. You just can't. It's no wonder that this book is challenged in some places. But I'm not a book banner. Obviously.

My rule is context, context, context. My second rule is that it is better to discuss and employ critical thinking skills than it is to deny, hide, or censor. There are two contexts for reading Gone With The Wind. The first is that of the author. Margaret Mitchell. A Southern woman growing up in turn-of-the-century America. The 1920s and the 1930s. These were the years that Margaret Mitchell was living and working on her novel. This is the culture and mindset of the author and of the original audience. Gone With The Wind is not alone. It doesn't stand out from the crowd. Many books, many authors used the n-word without batting an eye. Many wrote with the mindset that whites are superior--intellectually at least--to blacks. It doesn't make it true then or now. But that is the mindset. The second is that of the setting of the novel. 1860s-1870s America's South. You can't be true to history without going there. It's a fact in America's history. There's no disputing or denying it. It's not pleasant; it's often ugly. But there you have it. You've got to know where you've been so you can measure how far you've come. And so you can measure how far you've still got to go. America--both as a nation and as a people--has never been perfect. Will probably never be perfect.

As a reader, I can enjoy the story without being brainwashed. I can see. I can question. I can realize when I'm being fed bull. Lines where the former slaves still faithful servants are talking about how they've never wanted freedom??? about how they've never wanted money or independence??? I think I know that Mitchell was full of it. I think most readers can make that division. I hope.

Changing topics now. I just want to bring to your attention one more thing. The last chapter was written first. (The first few chapters were written last.) Margaret Mitchell had in her mind how the story would end. It was these characters in this last and final state--the frustrated and pleading Scarlett and the resolute and pitying Rhett--that were her characters. Her characters just as she wanted them; just as she first imagined them. Everything that comes before is leading up to this grand emotional finale. Every scene, every conversation. All the little plot twists. All were to lead up to this. It wasn't the other way around. The ending wasn't tacked on because Mitchell didn't know where to go next. This unhappy and emotionally draining scene was her perfect ending. Which is why I find the idea of sequels so laughable.

There is so much more I could say. How much I love Melanie. How much I love Rhett. How irritating Ashley can be. How unforgettable most of the character are when you get down to it. But if I were to post every thought I had on GWTW... then that would be much too much. If I were to share every *favorite* quote...again much too much.

I first read Gone With The Wind when I was eleven or twelve. (I had first typed elven. But I've never been elven.) I've read it maybe seven or eight times since then. I read it every year for a while. But around the age of twenty, I outgrew it. Moved on. This was my first time to read it since then.

© Becky Laney of Becky's Book Reviews

Thursday, March 27, 2008

Sense and Sensibility



Sense and Sensibility by Jane Austen. What can I say? I didn't love it like I loved (or loved, loved, loved) Persuasion or Pride and Prejudice. It was so different to Northanger Abbey in a way which makes it more difficult to compare. But in its favor, I didn't dislike it like I disliked Mansfeld Park or Emma. (A word on Emma's behalf. Emma, the character, annoys me. I know she's supposed to be annoying because she represents the young and foolish and rich and selfish and spoiled stereotype. But still. It's hard to like someone like that. It would be like reading a book told from Lydia's perspective. I wonder if anyone has done that???)

Sense and Sensibility is the story of the Dashwood family. The mother has recently been widowed. She's got a step-son who's inherited everything, and her own three daughters. She's also got a daughter-in-law from hell. Really. This woman would make even a saint think that. The two are somewhat indirectly pushed out the door by the couple--Mr. and Mrs. John Dashwood. They're insufferable to live with. And they're rude and pushy. Contemptible really. The only good thing that happens is that Elinor meets a young man, Edward Ferrars, and falls in love. Though nothing is promised or exchanged between them.

The Dashwoods (mother and three daughters: Elinor, Marianne, Margaret) move to a cottage quite a distance away. (Barton I believe is the place where they're staying.) While there, Marianne 'makes' two men fall in love with her. Colonel Brandon, a respectable but older gentleman, and the young and dashing and ever-so-handsome Mr. Willoughby. Marianne sees only Willoughby. Brandon doesn't stand a chance. They also meet many people in the neighborhood--Mrs. Jennings, the Middletons, the Palmers, the Steeles, etc.

The story centers around the love lives of the two older sisters Elinor and Marianne. Often the two are down on their luck. Money plays a big role in the novel. But Jane Austen loved happy endings so never fear. It may take a good many pages, but Marianne and Elinor are assured of finding men that suit them perfectly one way or another.

368 pages.
Originally published in 1811.
First sentence: The family of Dashwood had long been settled in Sussex.

© Becky Laney of Becky's Book Reviews

Saturday, March 22, 2008

To Sir Phillip, With Love



Quinn, Julia. 2003. To Sir Phillip, With Love.

To Sir Phillip, With Love is the fifth in the Bridgerton series, a historical romance series set in Regency England. To Sir Phillip, With Love, Romancing Mister Bridgerton, and When He Was Wicked are the three of the series that are most tightly woven together. The action of all three occur within the same few months of 1824.

During the ball scene (the big reveal) of Romancing Mister Bridgerton, Eloise Bridgerton was noticeably absent. There was a big reason. She used her sister and brother-in-law's party as her getaway. She, partly out of jealousy, has decided to do something a bit bold and a bit out of character. She's off to meet her pen pal, a widower with two kids. Their correspondence began the previous year when she wrote condolences upon his wife's death. The letters have given them both a bit of comfort, and on his suggestion, she is on her way to meet them. He wants to see if she'll suit him as a wife.

Phillip never expected Eloise to be attractive. He was expecting a spinster. An unattractive but intelligent companion. That is what he wanted. He definitely didn't expect to find someone so talkative, so opinionated, so set in her ways, so spunky.

But Eloise forgot one thing when making her journey. Okay, she forgot two things. She forgot to write him that she was coming so he hasn't a chaperone ready to receive her and supervise their courtship. But more importantly, she forgot that her family would be worried and quite frantic about her sudden disappearance. She forgot to count on her four brothers--three older, one younger--hunting her down in angry pursuit!!! Poor Phillip. I almost feel sorry for him!

Phillip's kids are another story. A set of 8 year old twins--one boy, one girl. And they're more than a handful. But if anyone can handle this situation, it is Eloise.

The book is enjoyable. The kids add something more to this historical romance novel. I've not read too many Regency romance novels where kids play a role--a big role--in the action.

372 pages.

Tuesday, March 18, 2008

Romancing Mister Bridgerton


Quinn, Julia. 2002. Romancing Mister Bridgerton.

Romancing Mister Bridgerton is my favorite and best. It is the fourth in a series of Regency romance novels by Julia Quinn focusing on the eight Bridgerton siblings: Anthony, Benedict, Colin, Daphne, Eloise, Francesca, Gregory, and Hyacinth. The fourth novel focuses on Colin Bridgerton. If you've read any of the previous novels you know that Colin is the favorite of many--both in and out of the family. His charm, his wit, his good nature make him quite the natural choice. (The other novels are The Duke and I, The Viscount Who Loved Me, and An Offer From a Gentleman. All feature glimpses of Colin.)

Penelope Featherington is not alone in her admiration of Colin Bridgerton. But she might be voted the least likely to marry a Bridgerton. In all honesty, she'd probably be voted least likely to marry anyone. Whether seventeen or twenty-eight, Penelope has always been Penelope. On the outside looking in, always waiting and watching and hoping all the while knowing that this spinsterhood is her destiny.

This is not our first introduction to Penelope. She has appeared in most of the other Bridgerton novels as well. (She has quite a memorable scene or two in An Offer From A Gentleman. And she played an important role in The Duke and I as well. I can't remember if she's got any lines in The Viscount Who Loved Me or not.)

Let me say now that this novel had me at hello.

On the sixth of April, in the year of 1812--precisely two days before her sixteenth birthday--Penelope Featherington fell in love.
It was, in a word, thrilling. The world shook. Her heart leaped. The moment was breathtaking. And, she was able to tell herself with some satisfaction, the man in question--one Colin Bridgerton--felt the same way.
Oh, not the love part. He certainly didn't fall in love with her in 1812, (and not in 1813, 1814, 1815, or--oh, blast, not in all the years 1816-1822, either, and certainly not in 1823, when he was out of the country the whole time anyway). But his earth shook, his heart leaped, and Penelope knew without a shadow of a doubt that his breath was taken away as well. For a good ten seconds.
Falling off a horse tended to do that to a man.

The book opens in 1824. Penelope has had plenty of years to dream and dream and dream about Colin from afar. As the best friend of Eloise, Penelope has long been a regular of the Bridgerton household. For teas. For visits. For parties and dances and balls. There's not a week that goes by where she hasn't spent several hours in the company of one or more Bridgertons. Colin does know she exists. He just doesn't see her in that way. He's not alone, no man thus far in her life has seen her in that way.

Besides being friends with the Bridgerton clan, Penelope has a rather chummy relationship with Lady Danbury, a woman in her seventies who's not afraid to speak her mind when she gets the notion. And lately Lady Danbury has been struck with the notion that Penelope is quite wonderful; unfortunately, not many people are aware of the fact of just how amazingly wonderful she is. But if Lady Danbury has her way, Penelope will soon have her day to shine.

It all starts with a dare, a bet. At a gathering (ball, party, dance), Lady Danbury startles everyone with a proclamation. Wouldn't it be fun to solve the riddle of who this Lady Whistledown really is? She offers a monetary reward. Solve the mystery and win the money. Lady Whistledown, for those unfamiliar with the novels or unfamiliar with my earlier reviews this week, writes a gossip or society column. Twice a week, the ton happily reads about themselves hoping to find praise and anxious to see who will be insulted.

The mystery is eventually solved and it might just keep you guessing for most of the novel.

I loved practically everything about this novel. The characters of Penelope and Colin are special favorites of mine.

An Offer From A Gentleman


Quinn, Julia. 2001. An Offer From A Gentleman.

An Offer From A Gentleman follows the Cinderella motif. True, the Bridgerton family isn't royalty. Benedict Bridgerton, the second son in the family, isn't technically a prince. But he does play the role of "Prince Charming" to a young woman, Sophie Beckett, quite well. Quite well indeed. Sophie, our heroine, is the illegitimate daughter of the Earl of Penwood. He treats her well enough, I suppose, but all that changes after he marries a widow with two daughters of his own. Especially after his death. Araminta plays the role of the wicked step-mother perfectly. (Think Ever After.) And Rosamund and Posy are the stepsisters. As you can guess, Sophie became a servant or slave to all after her father's death. The book begins with the family preparing to go to a ball. The Bridgerton's are hosting a masquerade ball. Sophie who follows the Bridgerton family quite closely through Lady Whistledown's Society Papers, wishes she could go, of course. It all sounds so splendid compared to the mundane details of her life--polishing shoes, mending dresses, serving tea, fixing hair, etc. Playing the role of fairy godmother, we have Mrs. Gibbons the housekeeper. Wearing her grandmother's clothes--dress, gloves, etc., soon Sophie is looking like a princess. Dressed in silver, she without a doubt captures the attention of Benedict. They share one perfect night--a few kisses, a few dances, but nothing shockingly indecent--she vanishes at midnight when the masks are to be removed and their identities revealed. Benedict searches in vain to find his perfect soul mate....

All that being the first eighty pages of the book.

The real heart of the story is what happens next. What happens if Prince Charming couldn't find his Cinderella quite so quickly. What happens if Cinderella-as-maid was right under his nose but he couldn't recognize her for who she is or who she was.

I don't want to say too much or too little. Benedict is a charming hero but not always the brightest hero. And Sophie isn't a saint by any means. But I loved them and I loved their story. This was the first of the Bridgerton series I'd read. I picked it up because I love Cinderella stories. What I encountered was a thoroughly enjoyable, thoroughly fleshed-out family that is full of heart, wit, humor, and spunkiness. Benedict is the second in a family of eight children. And while not all children get equal attention, those that do enter into the action are so enjoyable that you can't help but love them all. After reading this novel, I had to search out the others in the series. (At the time I read it, the series was ongoing.)

If you like regency romance novels.
If you like Cinderella stories.
If you like historical romance novels.
Then chances are you'll enjoy An Offer From A Gentleman by Julia Quinn.

358 pages
First sentence: This year's sought-after invitation must surely be that of the Bridgerton masquerade ball, to be held Monday next. Indeed, one cannot take two steps without being forced to listen to some society mama speculating on who will attend, and perhaps more importantly, who will wear what.

Sunday, March 16, 2008

The Viscount Who Loved Me


Quinn, Julia. 2000. The Viscount Who Loved Me.

The Viscount Who Loved Me is the second novel in the Bridgerton series, a series of regency romance novels by the talented and prolific Julia Quinn. Our hero is Anthony Bridgerton. Our heroine is the spunky Kate Sheffield. The setting is 1814, London.

The novel opens with a quote from Lady Whistledown's Society Papers:
The topic of rakes has, of course, been previously discussed in this column, and This Author has come to the conclusion that there are rakes, and there are Rakes.
Anthony Bridgerton is a Rake.
A rake (lower-case) is youthful and immature. He flaunts his exploits, behaves with utmost idiocy, and thinks himself dangerous to women.
A Rake (upper-case) knows he is dangerous to women.
He doesn't flaunt his exploits because he doesn't need to. He knows he will be whispered about by men and women alike, and in fact, he'd rather they didn't whisper about him at all. He knows who he is and what he has doen; further recountings are, to him, redundant.
He doesn't behave like an idiot for the simple reason that he isn't an idiot (any moreso than must be expected among all members of the male gender). He has little patience for the foibles of society, and quite frankly, most of the time This Author cannot say she blames him.
And if that doesn't describe Viscount Bridgerton--surely this season's most eligible bachelor--to perfection, This Author shall retire Her quill immediately. The only question is: Will 1814 be the season he finally succombs to the exquisite bliss of matrimony? This Author thinks...
Not.
Our heroine Kate is the older sister of Edwina. Edwina is young, beautiful, and quite the "it" girl of the season. Since Edwina's debut, Kate has been sharing the attention only because her sister let it slip that she would not marry without the consent of her older sister. So Edwina's beaus (or is it beaux?) are making sure to dance with her, to bring her flowers, say a few kind words. There intentions are obvious: they want to win Edwina's heart. Edwina knows (or thinks she knows) what she's looking for in a husband. Kate is also full of wisdom. And Kate is sure that a RAKE is not good husband-material no matter how attractive and charming they may be. So when Anthony Bridgerton starts courting Edwina, Kate lets her disapproval--her indignation--show!

Anthony and Kate have the kind of chemistry as Benedick and Beatrice. In other words, they don't get along. At least not at first. Yet the more time Anthony spends in the company of the Sheffields--both sisters--the more he's drawn to Kate. He doesn't want to admit it, not at first, but she is slowly but surely driving him crazy. But the good kind of crazy.

Anthony is not a perfect hero. He's not every girl's dream. For one thing, he has no intention of marrying for love. He has no intention of being faithful. He fears love more than he even fears death. Perhaps I need to back track a bit further, Anthony fears that he will die young. His father died at the age of 38. Anthony wants to marry and have a child or two. But love isn't part of the equation in his opinion. It would be just that much harder for him to die at peace. So he thinks. But his fears, his ideas, his plans will all begin to shift, to change as his encounters with Kate increase.

Anthony's three goals which he lays out at the very beginning:

1) She must be reasonably attractive (no raving beauty required)
2) She could NOT be stupid; he could live without intelligent conversation himself, but he didn't want stupid children.
3) She couldn't be anyone with whom he might actually fall in love.

The Viscount who loves me is a delightfully charming romance novel. Julia Quinn is always enjoyable and always trustworthy.

376 pages

Saturday, March 15, 2008

The Duke and I


Quinn, Julia. 2000. The Duke and I.

The Duke and I is the first novel in a series of eight books focusing on the Bridgerton family. There are eight Bridgerton siblings: Anthony, Benedict, Colin, Daphne, Eloise, Francesca, Gregory, and Hyacinth. (4 boys. 4 girls.) Each of the novels focuses on a Bridgerton and on the soon-to-be significant other of the Bridgerton in question. The Duke and I is narrated by Daphne and Simon. Simon is actually Simon Arthur Henry Fitzranulph Basset. (At his birth he was already an Earl, Earl Clyvedon). A child destined for greatness, upon his father's death he'd be the tenth Duke of Hastings.

The prologue sets Simon up as a troubled, bitter, and angry young man. His mother died giving birth to him. His father rejected him because of a childhood stutter. He's been raised by servants. His father lived on another estate and pretended he was dead. It was even hinted that he faked mourning for his son. (Though I could have misread that passage.) If there is one thing that is clear about Simon it is that he hates his father. Hates with a capital-H. He despises everything about him. Because of this angsty adolescence, Simon is not the marrying kind. He doesn't want to fall in love; he doesn't want to get married; he doesn't want to have children; he doesn't want to pass on his title.

The first chapter introduces us to two important characters. (Well, more than that really. But hear me out.) Lady Whistledown. The secret, mysterious authoress of a London's society (gossip) paper. Every chapter of this book (and most of the other Bridgerton series books) begins with a glorious snippet of juicy gossip from the pen of Lady Whistledown. These bits are pure fun, a pure delight to read. The book opens with Daphne and her mother reading that morning's edition of Lady Whistledown.

The heart of this novel revolves around marriage. Violet Bridgerton, the mother, is anxious (extremely anxious) to get her oldest son and oldest daughter married off. She has even given lists of eligible prospects to both. Anthony, as the head of the family since his father's death, is a Viscount and quite a catch. He is the one responsible for overseeing Daphne's courtship. (I don't know if that's the right word. He's in charge of who is allowed and not allowed to call on her, to decide who is a proper enough escort, etc. And ultimately the one to give "permission" for her hand in marriage.) Daphne is a lovely girl but one without many suitors. It's not that there are none, she was proposed to by several men in their late fifties and early sixties, it's just that no man has all of the necessary factors: the intelligence, the wit, the wealth, and the attractive appeal to win her heart or win her respect.

It is when Daphne is fleeing from an ardent (and quite drunk) gentleman, Nigel Berbrooke, that she meets Simon. (The setting is a dance, a ball. A ball at Lady Danbury's home.) Simon is ready to rescue this damsel in distress. Didn't he overhear her telling the gentleman to back off, to leave her alone? It's his duty, his privilege to save her. But before he has a chance to act, Daphne lets Nigel have it. He's down for the count. (I don't think she meant to floor him though! But she's used to standing up for herself and has certainly watched her brothers fighting.) Now Simon and Daphne are in cahoots about the situation. How to get him out of the hallway without causing a big scene. She isn't aware of who he is, but he knows almost from the very beginning that this dynamite of a girl who can pack a punch is the little sister of his good friend, Anthony, whom he attended school with all those years ago.

As soon as she does learn his identity, she lets it slip that her mother told her to stay away from him because he was a Rake. (A.K.A. mad, bad, and dangerous to know) Simon can't let this golden opportunity go, he tries to "scare" her with his ardent charm. It fails miserably. All he does is succeed in giving her the giggles. She tells him, "you shouldn't be so melodramatic. It doesn't suit you. . .Well, actually, it does suit you, I ought to admit . . .You looked quite dangerous. And very handsome, of course. . .That was your intention, was it not? Of course it was. And I would be remiss if I did not tell you that you would have been successful with any other woman besides me." (57) She proceeds to tell him, "I'm quite flattered you thought me worthy of such a magnificent display of dukish rakishness...or do you prefer rakish dukishness?" (58)

The chemistry is there alright. The banter between the two, the easy-going friendship of sorts that starts to form from the very beginning. It all makes for an interesting proposition. Not that kind of proposition either. He wants to woo her, to court her, to keep all the other Ambitious Mamas away along with all their daughters for the season. She agrees because she knows that being wooed by him will make her attractive to all the other men. After she's really and truly fallen in love with someone, she can be the one to end their engagement or courtship or relationship. They both think it's a good (and slightly manipulative) way to maneuver in a society obsessed with the marriage mart. (Her mother won't be after her to find a man because she thinks her daughter is being courted by a duke...quite a catch.) The one with the doubts? Anthony. He knows Simon's reputation. He shares Simon's reputation. He knows exactly the kind of man Simon is. Can he really trust Simon to keep his hands off his sister?

This is a delicious novel. As you can imagine, Simon does put Daphne in a compromising position. And Anthony is all for a shotgun wedding or a duel.

Can Daphne persuade Simon that marriage with her really would be better than certain death?

There is a reason--a very very good reason--that Julia Quinn is my favorite romance novelist. Her books are always well written. (Formulaic in parts yes, but always well written.) Her Bridgerton novels are especially delightful. For Quinn's novels are always always always more than just a lame excuse for (corny) graphic sex. It really is about the characters. Really is about the story. In my opinion, most other novelists have flat characters. The whole book revolves around the smut. You could essentially mix and match heroes and heroines from any romance novel and the novels would read the same. I don't like [insert-name-here] love scenes. I don't. Which is why an occasional Quinn novel will slip into my tbr pile. Yes, it's a guilty-pleasure to indulge in adult romance novels. But reading Quinn is not as guilty and as shameful as indulging in other authors. (She has more nutrition and nourishment for the mind than most others.)

The Rules of Gentility


Mullany, Janet. 2007. The Rules of Gentility.

I was on my way to check out at the library when my eyes happened to catch this title: The Rules of Gentility. I took it off the shelf and read, "Mullany is clearly the witty, secret love child of Jane Austen and Lord Byron." Interesting. Very interesting. As you can imagine, that alone was enough to make me bring it home. Though I didn't know it at the time, the back cover also reads, "A delightful marriage of Pride and Prejudice with Bridget Jones's Diary." That also would have helped persuade me to give this new-to-me author a chance.

First sentence:
It is a truth universally acknowledged that a single woman of fortune and passable good looks amuses herself in London with fashion, philanthropic works, and flirtation, until a suitable gentleman makes an offer. I consider the pursuit of the bonnets and a husband fairly alike--I do not want to acquire an item that will wear out, or bore me after a brief acquaintance, and we must suit each other very well. And although I have several gentlemen who have expressed an interest, I find all of them lack a certain something; and of course, with a gentleman you cannot replace the trim from another to make the perfect object, as tempting a thought as that might be, although indeed it would be an interesting experiment.
(1-2)

Our heroine is Miss Philomena Wellesley-Clegg. When our text opens, we find Miss Philomena on her way to visit her good friend, Julia, Lady Terrant. On the way in, however, she first bumps into a strange man. A man she mistakes for a servant. His name? Inigo Linsley. And, of course, he is no servant. He is the brother-in-law of Julia. A man who stands to inherit quite a nice bit of property if and only if he agrees to settle down and marry a nice girl. (Of course, our heroine doesn't know this last bit quite yet.) The novel alternates between those two narrators: Inigo and Philomena. Philomena, Julia, and several other young ladies (mostly single ladies I believe) have formed a philanthropic club called the Association for the Rescue and Succor of those in Extremis.

It is obvious from the beginning that Inigo has captured her interest, her attention. (I won't say heart. It's simply not true.) She has a list of eligible men. And she deliberately keeps trying to keep him off her list. But he always has a way of popping right back on her list. He intrigues her much too much.

I shall be wise and virtuous concerning Mr. Linsley. I may practice flirting with him, and I may even dance with him at the ball tonight, but I shall certainly not allow him to take liberties of any sort whatsoever, even if I think no one would find out. Absolutely not. Besides, it is as Hen says--his family, who are proud and haughty, would never allow even their youngest and most insignificant son to marry into Trade, and I am sure Mama and Papa would not allow me to form an alliance with a man of such bad reputation. Not that I should wish to do such a thing. I do hope he will wear the dark blue satin coat and breeches tonight, but I resolve to think no more about the latter, which are pleasingly tight, and where, for some reason, I cannot help looking. (34)

Soon the two are courting in jest--a "false engagment" for her to discourage a bothersome beau and for him to get his meddling and nagging brother to leave him alone. But as can be expected, this false courtship soon feels all-too-real to both parties.

The text is fun and flirty in that giddy girlish way. The kind of book that makes you feel good when you read it, a big grin, a few snickers and giggles, but the kind that you feel a bit guilty or sheepish about as well. It isn't your stereotypical bodice-ripping romance novel with a half-naked couple on the cover. It's higher quality than that by all means. It definitely falls into the category of chick lit. Historical chick lit. (You don't often find that!) The concerns are shopping and partying and dating and love. On the sliding scale of if it is 'clean' or 'smutty' I'd say it was PG-13. Not R. Not X. But definitely full of flirtatious innuendos. (Not as clean or as appropriate as Georgette Heyer's novels. But definitely way cleaner than your average romance novel.)

Those familiar with Regency romance novels know that one of the standard story lines is that of a Rake who becomes quite reformed and quite a good husband because of the love and care and devotion of that one, sweet, charming, unforgettable girl. Meeting "the one" makes him forget all the scores of women he's bedded and makes him quite the catch. These heroes are always "mad, bad, and dangerous to know" (Byron) but always reform-able.

While the story might not be that original, the characters, and certainly the writing style are enjoyable. I would describe this one as definitely fun. Pure fun. Not "pure" pure fun. I loved every minute of this novel. I wouldn't hesitate to recommend this one. But I would imagine it's not for everyone. If the idea of a "witty, secret love child" of Austen and Byron intrigues you, I'd encourage you to pick it up.

Tuesday, February 26, 2008

Earthly Pleasures



Neches, Karen. 2008. Earthly Pleasures.

I rarely read Amazon reviews these days. I typically don't second guess my opinion. (And for the record, I'm not second guessing it here either even though I did look the book up on Amazon. The only thing I'm second guessing is whether to give it 3 stars or 3.5 stars or 3.75 stars.) But I have to say that Publishers Weekly's phrasing of "appealingly unorthodox" is just right in describing this fun, often light-hearted debut novel, Earthly Pleasures. Set both in heaven and on earth, it follows the lives of many characters--some living, some not so much. The story lines are seemingly unconnected--unconnected but enjoyable nonetheless--until the last third of the book when everything begins to come together. It is a romance. An unusual romance, but a romance all the same. The man? A celebrity both in heaven and on earth. Ryan Blaine. The woman? Well, when we first meet her she's a 'greeter' in heaven. Skye Sebring. Where they meet. How they meet. When they meet. I'll leave that up to you to discover.

Expect a sweet, often-funny story of two lovers that seemingly will never have the chance to connect. Don't expect an orthodox vision of heaven. Don't. If you do, if you read it through the mindset of "this is wrong; this is wrong; that's wrong, too" you'll be missing out on a charming story. Theologically weak--at least for Christian believers that may come across this novel--the novel's strength is in its telling. The back cover for instance mentions that the heroine "discovers that all of life's lessons can be learned from the lyrics of five Beatles songs." As a Beatle fan, how could I really resist such a tale?

This book may not be for everyone. Some--myself excluded--might find it a bit too light, a bit too fluffy, a bit too predictable. Romance novels aren't suited for all readers after all. And one person's "best book ever" is sentimental trash to another. But I enjoyed myself greatly with this one. It was fun. Pure fun. Guilty fun.

First sentence: The red light on Skye Sebring's computer blinked rapidly, announcing the arrival of her first client of the day. Within seconds a girl with dark, darting eyes entered the cubicle. She wore spiked leather wrist cuffs and a T-shirt with the logo "Hustle or Die."

309 pages.

Friday, February 08, 2008

Wives and Daughters


Gaskell, Elizabeth. 1866. Wives and Daughters.

To begin with the old rigmarole of childhood. In a country there was a shire, and in that shire there was a town, and in that town there was a house, and in that house there was a room, and in that room there was a bed, and in that bed there lay a little girl; wide awake and longing to get up, but not daring to do so for fear of the unseen power in the next room; a certain Betty, whose slumbers must not be disturbed until six o'clock struck, when she wakened of herself 'as sure as clockwork' and left the household very little peace afterwards. It was a June morning, and early as it was, the room was full of sunny warmth and light.

This first chapter introduces us to a young Molly Gibson. She's around twelve at the time give or take a little. And she is most eager to go to her 'first' 'real' social event: a tea hosted by the Lord and Lady of the region--Lord and Lady Cumnor. The Cumnor's estate--they have several--in the region was called The Towers. (Usually they reside elsewhere. This is definitely just their country vacation home.) At this grand party, the young girl gets bored wanders into the gardens, falls asleep, is later discovered by the former-governess-then widow, Mrs. Kirkpatrick. (The family STILL calls her Miss Clare.) This discovery ruins the day for her. It's not that the family treats her poorly, it's just that when Mrs. Kirkpatrick tells the young girl to rest from being out in the sun (or some such notion) in her room, the girl falls asleep and misses her ride home. So she awakens hours later alone and confused and wanting to go home and be with her dad. (Her mother died when she was just a wee thing.) Her dad, the doctor, a somewhat dignified, genuinely respected doctor, comes to her rescue, however, and she's saved the embarrassment of having to sleep over.

A few chapters later Molly has grown from twelve to sixteen. She's becoming a young lady, an attractive young lady. And her father is noticing the transition. Feeling overwhelmed by the thought of raising her alone, he decides to remarry. It's not that he decides this overnight. At first he resists the notion. But as the idea sits with him, it grows on him more and more. When he discovers that Mrs. Kirkpatrick is once again visiting The Towers (after quite a few years absence from the region) he decides to call on the family and see if she might not do as a wife. He knows or vaguely remembers that she has a daughter around Molly's age. He hopes that the idea of raising a daughter without a father will seem equally daunting to her as raising a daughter without a mother.

Molly is SO NOT HAPPY with the idea of a stepmother and stepsister.

And here my summary must stop. The book is long 648 pages. But it is good in a steady kind of way. It is slow; It is steady; It is good; It improves with each bit. (What do I mean by "bit"? Well, the descriptions seem heavy and largely unnecessary--very weighty--at the very beginning. But towards the middle and especially at the end, it begins to make sense. These descriptive bits which you take for fluff at first, are meant to pad the resulting pages. In other words, they help explain or fill out or give substance to the rest. It's not that you'll desperately need that information, but it will make more sense and be a better read if you resist the urge to skip and skim. Gaskell has a HUGE task. She brings to life a whole community. From the Gibsons to the Kirkpatricks to the Cumnors to the Hamleys to the town busybodies. A real panoramic, sweeping view or portrait of life.

Sunday, October 14, 2007

Romance Reading Challenge


The Bookworm is hosting a challenge for 2008 called the Romance Reading Challenge. She is asking that participants choose five romance novels. They don't have to be *smutty* romance novels either. Classics like Pride & Prejudice by Jane Austen or Evelina by Frances Burney or something by the Bronte sisters will do as well.

Since I will be hosting the mini-Austen challenge in 2008, I am going to be trying to read the six Austen novels: Emma, Mansfield Park, Northanger Abbey, Persuasion, Pride and Prejudice, and Sense and Sensibility.

I'd also love to read Gone With The Wind (Back to History Challenge, Book Awards Challenge) by Margaret Mitchell.

And possibly Christy by Catherine Marshall as well. (Back to History Challenge)

I'm sure many of my Christian titles would qualify as well, though I don't think I'll try to make them 'official' reads for this challenge.