Friday, February 04, 2022

21. Linked


Linked. Gordon Korman. 2021. 256 pages. [Source: Library]

First sentence: My mother says I'd lose my head if it wasn't attached to my body.

Premise/plot: When a swastika is painted on the walls of a small town middle school, well, prepare for quite a shake-up among the teachers and staff, the students, the parents and community at large. Who painted it...and why?

This middle grade novel has multiple narrators...mainly students, but not exclusively students. Together the pieces begin to fit together. But sometimes there are more questions than answers.

After the first swastika is painted, the students (eventually) come together (after weeks of tolerance training) and decide that action must be taken...and that action, well, it proves inspiring.

That action is making a paper chain with six million links. One link for every Jewish person who was killed/murdered/died during the Holocaust. In making this chain, the number begins to sink in...so many lives lost and each life mattered, each life ended too soon, each is to be remembered forever.

My thoughts: This one is contemporary realistic fiction set in a small Colorado town. Each narrator contributes to the big picture. I found it a compelling but frustrating read. I'll try to explain, there were certain things that frustrated me about how the story plays out. But I don't think you could call it unrealistic. In trying to understand the 'why' of how someone--someone their own age--could do this....perhaps there are no satisfactory reasons.

Of course, there is the WHO. I will not spoil the review. I won't. I think the only way to make it through this one is not to know who painted it...too soon. But my reaction to the story/plot changed as the story unfolded. I thought some elements of the story worked better than others.

I have so many thoughts on the WHO and how that story plays out. But I don't want to write a review that would spoil the book for new readers.

 

© 2022 Becky Laney of Becky's Book Reviews

20. The Genius Under the Table


The Genius Under the Table: Growing Up Behind the Iron Curtain. Eugene Yelchin. 2021. 208 pages. [Source: Library]

First sentence: The first time I saw real American tourists, they hopped out of a tourist bus in Red Square in Moscow and cut in front of us in line. "Nice manners!" my mother shouted. "We've been freezing our butts off for hours and they just breeze in like that?" We were in line to the mausoleum where the founder of our country, Vladimir I. Lenin, was laid out embalmed like an Egyptian mummy. To see him, you had to wait your turn.

Premise/plot: Yevgeny, our narrator, is growing up (seemingly) talent-less in a country that very much demands talent--if you want to succeed. Genius Under the Table is a memoir, of sorts, of growing up in Communist Russia during the Cold War. 

His parents are pleased that their oldest son is so talented, a pairs figure skater. He will get the chance to travel the world, to one day have his own apartment, his own car perhaps. The possibilities are not without some limits, perhaps. But he's got the potential to have some wiggle room, some tokens of freedom. But Yevgeny, well, he seems to have no talent that offer him any hope of a good future, at least within their country. But what his parents don't realize--especially in the first half of the book--is that Yevgeny does have a talent...a talent that he himself doesn't know makes him special. Every night he draws with a (stolen from his father) pencil underneath the family's antique dining table. The table being even older than Grandma.

The family lives in a shared apartment. All the family living in one room and sharing some common spaces (the hall, a bathroom, a kitchen) with other families. 

The book is a coming-of-age memoir.

My thoughts: It is both dark and funny. It definitely doesn't shy away from some tough subjects...including racism (he's Jewish), death (I won't spoil it), and politics. (Growing up in a Communist country, freedom of speech is unheard of...even in one's own apartment. You could be turned in by anyone for speaking out, criticizing, questioning.) It is 100% coming of age. It is all about finding one's own place, one's own voice, seeking this place of belonging and rightness with the world. Of course, this is complicated by where he is growing up.

I really found it an absorbing, compelling read. There were scenes that just touched me. The writing was great. It is an illustrated book.

However, if I could change one thing about this one, it would be the addition of specific dates--years, I mean. The narrator is young--ten? eleven? twelve? if I had to guess. If we assume (like the description states) that it is the author's memoir, then that would place it in the mid-to-late sixties. (Yelchin was born in 1956.) Yet, the one event that we can definitely attach an actual-actual date to is the defection of Mikhail Baryshnikov, June 1974. The author was definitely much older (a late teen) in 1974. So he has made himself younger perhaps to make a better fit for a children's book. Not a deal breaker by any means, but, as an adult I want dates so I can get a better context of how this story fits in with history. Kids, well, I'm going to guess that kids wouldn't be bothered at all by lack of dates. They won't be trying to fit in this story with what they already know about this time period in history.

 Quote:

Life seemed like an enormous puzzle to me then, and drawing helped order the pieces: Mom, Dad, Victor, Grandma, Lenin, the Americans, even Baryshnikov. Each piece was a different shape. I was a puzzle piece, too, but I was made in such a wrong shape that I was convinced I would never fit in anywhere. The only place I fit in well was under Grandma’s table, drawing to the soft squeak of the stolen pencil.

© 2022 Becky Laney of Becky's Book Reviews

Thursday, February 03, 2022

19. Our Mutual Friend


Our Mutual Friend. Charles Dickens. 1865. 801 pages. [Source: Bought]

I first read this one in 2011. I don't know why it took me over a decade to reread this one. Since I found it so hard to summarize the first time, I am reposting my initial review. (The plot didn't change after all).

My thoughts, well, they stayed just as enthusiastic or gushy. I still love, love, love this one. This is still my favorite Dickens novel.

First sentence: IN THESE TIMES of ours, though concerning the exact year there is no need to be precise, a boat of dirty and disreputable appearance, with two figures in it, floated on the Thames, between Southwark bridge which is of iron, and London Bridge which is of stone, as an autumn evening was closing in.

How does one begin to describe a novel that is 800 pages long?! A novel that doesn't have one or two main characters--but many. A novel that doesn't have one or two main stories--but many. If you're not familiar with Charles Dickens, you should know that he has his own way of storytelling. His stories and characters unfold slowly but surely. Don't expect to meet all the main characters in the first hundred pages. Or even the first two hundred pages. Dickens won't be rushed. This is something that I have come to appreciate--though other readers may struggle with his pacing. I found it delightful; something to be savored.

Since I have to start somewhere, perhaps I should start with the corpse. Lizzie Hexam and her father, Jesse "Gaffer" Hexam discover a dead body during their night's work on the Thames. Her father's former business partner, Roger Riderhood, witnesses this discovery and later has some unflattering stories to spread to any willing to listen. (Stories that threaten Lizzie Hexam and her brother, Charley.) The body was soon identified as John Harmon--there were clothes and papers identifying him, I think. His death brings changes to several households. For his intended, Miss Bella Wilfer, it ushers in pitifully insincere mourning. She mourns--but for the riches she would have had if they'd married and he'd inherited his father's estate. But the household that changes the most is that of the Boffins. For Mr. and Mrs. Boffin will inherit the Harmon estate now that the heir is dead. Will money prove friend or foe to this lovely couple? One thing we learn early on, is that Mr. Boffin has a heart of gold--for he opens his heart and home to Miss Bella Wilfer. He also hires two men--two very different men--after he comes into his money: Silas Wegg, a man he hired to read to him, and John Rokesmith, a man he hired as his secretary. Is either man who he appears to be?

What did I love best about this one? The characters? I loved Bella Wilfer, John Rokesmith, Mr. and Mrs. Boffin, Melvin Tremlow, Jenny Wren, Mr. Riah, and Lizzie Hexam. And there were characters that I didn't exactly love--they weren't that lovable, after all--but their scenes were enjoyable nevertheless. The Podsnaps. The Veneerings. The Lammles. The Wilfers. Mr. Fledgeby. Mr. Lightwood and Mr. Wrayburn. Some characters added drama; some characters added humor!

Dickens did a great job with his characters. You'll find characters that you'll absolutely love and adore. You'll find characters that are so enjoyable, so fun, to spend time with. You'll find characters that make you laugh--or at least smirk. You might find a few characters that you love to hate, or hate to love. You'll find characters that are just so despicable, so nasty, so horrid that you hate them--with a passion. There might even be a few that drive you crazy! But I hope that you'll find a few characters that genuinely surprise you! I know a few surprised me! There are so many characters. Some are very important to the plot. Others are very minor. But just because they're minor doesn't mean they're pointless. I loved the romances of Bella and Lizzie. 

 The scenes with Bella and her true love made me giddy! And while Lizzie's scenes were a different nature--a bit more melancholy--they were so heartfelt. But it isn't just a romance. There is action, drama, mystery. There are secrets and lies and malicious plotting.


I loved this one. I loved the writing, the descriptions, the characterizations, the storytelling. It's a great, great book.
"Never was an obstinate person yet, who would own to the word!" remarked Miss Potterson, rubbing her vexed nose; "I'm sure I would if I was obstinate; but I am a pepperer, which is different." (74)
"No one is useless in this world," retorted the Secretary, "who lightens the burden of it for any one else."
"But I assure you I don't, Mr. Rokesmith," said Bella, half-crying.
"Not for your father?"
"Dear, loving, self-forgetting, easily-satisfied Pa! Oh, yes! He thinks so."
"It is enough if he only thinks so," said the Secretary. (511-12)

 I don't have a page number for these two, but:

He was too tired to rest in his sleep, until he was even tired out of being too tired, and dropped into oblivion.

People are always calling other people something.


 

© 2022 Becky Laney of Becky's Book Reviews

Wednesday, February 02, 2022

18. The Last Cuentista


The Last Cuentista. Donna Barba Higuera. 2021. 336 pages. [Source: Library]

First sentence: Lita tosses another pinon log onto the fire. Sweet smoke drifts past us into the starry sky. Her knees crack as she sits back down on the blanket next to me. The cup of hot chocolate with cinnamon she's made me sits untouched this time.

Premise/plot: Petra Peña, our heroine, might just be humanity's last chance to stay connected with our troubled past. The Collective has seemingly won the ultimate victory--making nauseating sacrifices all for a 'good cause.' What better way to protect humanity's future than to completely annihilate any memory of our past. (Even wiping away memories of the planet Earth.) But perhaps I'm rushing things a bit?

The novel opens with a few spaceships getting ready to leave Earth behind. Earth's destruction literally being days (perhaps less than one???) away. The deed being done by a comet. It will take hundreds of years to arrive on Sagan, the new planet believed to be capable of supporting life. Petra, her family, and the other families selected will be making the journey in stasis.

But the humans guarding the sleepers, well, they have thoughts, opinions, ideas that are radically dangerous. Dangerous might not be the right word--deadly might suit better. If memories cannot be totally erased and new programming rewritten, well then, OOPS, that's just a necessary sacrifice.

Petra seems to be the only one to retain her memories. Memories packed with stories, stories, and more stories. Being found out--or found out too soon--may be costly. It will take wisdom to know when to make her move, to act against the Collective... And even then resistance may prove futile. And even if dozens of things go right, well, the odds may not be in her favor. An unexplored planet with a million uncertainties. Still, she's humanity's last chance to REMEMBER, to reflect.

 My thoughts: Newbery Medal 2022. It's impossible to read Newbery winners with a completely open mind and low expectations. (Which, in my opinion, is how most books should be read for the highest degree of enjoyment.)

On the one hand, it celebrates stories, storytelling, and storytellers. It celebrates the notions that stories not only entertain but they inform as well. Stories help us make sense or process the world around us. Ourselves. Others. Life. Stories matter because even fiction (or in this case folklore) can contain truths that make us better. Maybe better isn't the right word. Stories contain truths that can give us an opportunity to think, engage, learn, grow, reflect, etc. Emotions and feelings can be chaotic, messy, overwhelming...stories help us manage life.

The book is political in that many, many science fiction stories are political. The book is essentially a dystopia set on a spaceship and another planet. Dystopias are almost always political because they show us power gone sour. The Collective is BAD news obviously. But how did the Collective come to be? That we really don't have a lot of answers for. Except that we know that the Collective is built on this one idea that knowledge of the past, our history, is irrevocably dangerous to our survival. Wipe out ALL memories of our mistakes, conflicts, tragedies, abuses, injustices, wars, etc., and humanity has a chance. In the same way that the futuristic society of The Giver celebrates SAMENESS. The Collective fears DIFFERENCES.
It asks the question--what is the value--is there value--in history? The Collective perhaps started out rewriting or revising history before changing tactics to annihilating and destroying.

I would argue that history always matters. Whether it be denial or revision, you can't learn from the past that you disconnect from. 

On the other hand, I really HATED the ending. Or non-ending if you will. I don't like endings where you are CLUELESS what happens and what it means. It might as well be written in a foreign language as far as I'm concerned. I've read the last few pages a few times, and still, I'm like what does it mean? what happened? what is about to happen? was it good? was it bad?

© 2022 Becky Laney of Becky's Book Reviews

Tuesday, February 01, 2022

17. Exodus


Exodus. Leon Uris. 1958. 610 pages. [Source: Library]

First sentence: The airplane plip-plopped down the runway to a halt before the big sign: WELCOME TO CYPRUS.

Don't read Exodus expecting a grand, sweeping love story between a man and a woman. It is not a romance. I didn't go into it thinking it was a romance, but, at the same time you could isolate a few chapters here and there and get the wrong impression. I have--as of the writing of this review--not seen the film adaptation. I don't know if the movie portrays it as a great romance or not. 

The novel focuses on the birth of the nation of Israel in the twentieth century. While there are plenty of flashbacks (and more flashbacks) most of the action occurs 1946-1948. The nation of Israel is without a doubt the main character. Probably. I suppose one could argue that the main character is collectively speaking the Jewish people. This novel is ALL ABOUT the conflict. The opposing views, the ongoing struggles that surround the 'birth' of Israel. We get glimpses from all viewpoints.

Of course, there are a few (human) main characters. Kitty Fremont, an American nurse who only reluctantly goes to Palestine, is one of the main characters. At the beginning, she is a bit clueless. Why would any Jewish person--she wonders--choose to go to Palestine and 'rough it' in that country where they are not wanted when they could settle in America (for example) and have an 'easy' time of it. Why struggle in a harsh land where you both men and women will have to fight, fight, fight, fight, and fight some more to stay? She doesn't get the appeal of Palestine for the Jews. Of course, at the beginning, she still sees Jews as "other" or odd. She feels saddened and sympathetic to the plight of Jews after learning of the Holocaust, but she doesn't particularly like or understand. I'd describe her as sympathetic from a distance. But she finds herself thrown right in the middle. She meets a young Jewish teen, Karen, and there is an instant bond (at least on her side). Karen becomes her family--unofficially. She dreams of wooing Karen away from her hopes and dreams of settling in Palestine and settling down with Karen back in America. She only goes (or mainly goes) to Palestine because she is following Karen.

Of course, that's only half the equation. Kitty Fremont is also oddly enamored with Ari Ben Canaan. She would never in a hundred million years say "I have a crush on Ari Ben Canaan." But she finds him mesmerizing to a certain degree. And it is mutual. She isn't his ideal either--far from it. She's an American woman whose values, beliefs, and culture are so removed from his own. But they find themselves circling each other, reluctant to admit perhaps that there is something going on...

But this is not a romance. I repeat, not a romance. Don't pick this one up thinking Kitty and Ari have this GREAT love affair. It is politics and war; war and politics.

It is about a nation and the people who are willing to give their all--even their very lives--to see her come into being and thrive.

 

© 2022 Becky Laney of Becky's Book Reviews