Thursday, March 25, 2010

Falling In (MG)


Falling In. Frances O'Roark Dowell. 2010. [March 2010] Simon & Schuster. 245 pages.

On the morning this story begins, Isabelle Bean was convinced she was teetering on the edge of the universe.

Isabelle Bean is such a lonely little girl. She's always felt out of place, like she just doesn't belong. True, Isabelle is a strange child, at times. But a strangely true child. True to herself, true to who she is.

You know her, of course. Isabelle Bean is the girl who sits in the back corner of the classroom near the pencil sharpener. She isn't invisible, exactly, but she might as well be. She hardly ever speaks unless spoken to (and then only in riddles), never makes eye contact, has bangs that hang down almost to her nose so even if somebody wanted to look her straight in the eye, they couldn't.
It goes without saying that very few people want to look Isabelle Bean straight in the eye.
It's not that she smells bad. She doesn't. She takes a bath every night. And it's not that she's dumb, although it's true she has a bad habit of not doing her homework except when she really feels like it, which is almost never.
And it's not that Isabelle Bean is a bully. She's never beaten anyone up or even made the smallest threat. No one is physically scared of her, except for a few of the very nice girls in Mrs. Sharpe's class, girls whose hair smells like apple blossoms and whose mothers still read them bedtime stories. These are the girls who sharpen their pencils at home so they never have to walk near Isabelle's desk. (13-14)
When we first meet Isabelle, she is getting in trouble. Again. She's soon on her way to see the Vice Principal. But she'll never get there. No, because some doors are magical. Some doors lead to other worlds. And Isabelle, our lonely little heroine, may just find herself falling in.

The world Isabelle finds herself in is strange. The children speak of a witch, not just any witch, but the witch. Someone who has been hunting and eating children for decades. There is great fear surrounding this woman, this creature. And Isabelle's quick appearance, and her red, pointy shoes lead to some distrust. Is she the witch? If she's not the witch, is she in league with the witch? It seems Isabelle has fallen into a mystery. Can Isabelle learn the truth, discover the real story?

I really loved elements of Falling In. I found the writing to be well done. I especially loved Dowell's descriptions. And I did love Isabelle Bean. But. It's not a perfect novel. I think it showed great promise in the beginning. (And it did keep me turning pages, which says something.) I just wish the ending had been slightly different. The last chapter didn't quite work for me. Overall, I did enjoy this one.

© Becky Laney of Becky's Book Reviews

4 comments:

Melissa 5:59 PM  

I like Dowell's stuff, so I'll probably get to this eventually. But, I'm sorry it didn't hold up all the way through.

bestbookihavenotread 10:10 AM  

I've loved some of Dowell and been lukewarm to others. Had hoping this would be in the love category.

bestbookihavenotread 10:10 AM  

I've loved some of Dowell and been lukewarm to others. Had hoping this would be in the love category.

Robin of My Two Blessings 9:15 PM  

Sounds interesting. Will have to check it out.

Post a Comment

I'm always happy to hear from you! To help fight spam, comment moderation has been set up for posts older than two days. Feel free to ask me questions or ask for recommendations!

Unique Visitors and Google PR Rank

Free PageRank Checker

Pageloads Counter

The background is based on a background I found here...with some small adjustments on my part so it would work with the template.
Becky Laney of Becky's Book Reviews

  © Blogger template Newspaper III by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP