The Renaissance of Gwen Hathaway. Ashley Schumacher. 2023. [March] 320 pages. [Source: Library]
First sentence from prologue: I was ten when I first met the Wizened Old Wizard.
First sentence from chapter one: I wonder what the wizard would tell me now, if he could see me standing with my elbows resting atop the stone wall looking down below into the lazy river moat with literal alligator floaties. I wonder what he would say if he could see my swirling thoughts.
Premise/plot: Madeline Hathaway, our heroine, is mourning the loss of her mother. The first year anniversary of her death is approaching. She and her father will be spending the summer working at one of their favorite renaissance fairs. (They travel the circuit. They used to--all three--travel the circuit. It's been different since she's died. Both are grieving in their own way. Readers don't really glimpse *how* he is handling things, but Madeline journals every little thing--literally. She's a chronicle notice-r. She tallies every little thing--day after day, week after week, month after month. (Every time she does something; sees something; feels something; hears something; etc.) When the novel opens, she is about to meet Arthur, a wonderfully weird kid whose dads are equally obsessed with all things Renaissance. These two kings of the faire [or is it fair?] want--at Arthur's insistence--Madeline (whom Arthur calls Gwen) to be the princess, to play the role of princess. She's hesitant and anxious. But after some thought she thinks her mom would *want* her to do this--to step outside of her comfort zone of peasant/peddler and be a princess for a change. As she gets to know Arthur, she begins having many other unexpected adventures... But are these summer changes permanent?
My thoughts: I liked this one. It was premise-driven, in my opinion, though that's not necessarily a bad thing. I thought a few scenes were unrealistic. Granted, I haven't been in Target lately, but I've never once had any employee volunteer to be my personal shopper and hand-select clothes for me to try on, to be at my own beck and call and bring all the sizes, give opinions on what works and what doesn't. That scene feels like a movie-montage-wanna-be. Again, my opinion. Maybe it was just a really slow day?
Madeline is a larger heroine, and, it's nice to see that in a romance. She's much more than just a size, obviously. And I do wish--at least a little bit--that it wasn't such a plot point. Oh this boy couldn't possibly like me because I'm too large to be likeable. I mean it's the trope. And it's a trope that usually brings satisfaction--lovable heroine realizes she was beautiful all along...
Madeline's dad is very absent--physically, mentally, emotionally. He's just always gone. Perhaps because she is trying to avoid him???? Or perhaps he is trying to avoid her???? But it's rare for them to be in the same place and actually talk. This is typical YA, of course. Parents rarely if ever play an important role however. Arthur's two dads, on the other hand, are VERY present--physically, mentally, emotionally. They are scene-stealers. Madeline has a million conversations with Arthur's parent(s)....very few with her own. They are everything her own father is not.
© 2023 Becky Laney of Becky's Book Reviews
No comments:
Post a Comment