The Daughter of Time. Josephine Tey. 1951/1995. Simon & Schuster. 208 pages.
I have been wanting to
reread Josephine Tey's The Daughter of Time for quite a while now. The
more I read on Richard III, the more I want to read. I just find this
time period to be oh-so-fascinating. And the more you read, the easier
it is to keep track of who's who and who's loyal and who's not. In this
Alan Grant mystery, a bed-ridden Grant turns to solving a historical
mystery since he can't be working on any actual cases. A friend knowing
of his boredom, of his whining, brings him a stack of portraits, hoping
that one face will interest him more than the others perhaps. Grant
chooses Richard III. He vaguely remembers his story, but, he wants to
refresh his memory. So he begins by reading school books, then
historical fiction, and then biography, etc. Grant becomes very
opinionated on what he reads, judging that what passes as historical
fact wouldn't be acceptable as evidence or proof in court. In other
words, he finds the history books to be all gossip. For example, the
biography that is supposedly so esteemed, the author would have been
FIVE years old when Richard III was on the throne. Yet he writes as if
he was an eyewitness to the dramatic events. Grant argues (mostly with
himself and perhaps also with his two nurses) that at best the man's
facts would be just stories he'd heard from others and written down.
Since the biographer grew up and came into power during the Tudors--who
had every reason in the world for hating and slandering Richard
III--then the stories passed down to him would have bias to them. Who
would make a hero out of Richard III when Henry VII or Henry VIII
reigned?! He finds a kindred spirit in an American researcher named
Brent Carradine. Since Grant is stuck in bed, Carradine is the man doing
the hard work, digging into research. Together they discuss the facts
as they see them, Grant arranges the facts seeing what he can piece
together, seeing if he can make a narrative that works. He just can't
believe that Richard III murdered his two nephews. Grant believes that
Richard is the one with the least motive to want them dead. For their
deaths do him no good whatsoever, just harm.
The Daughter of Time
isn't your typical mystery novel. The detective essentially just stays
in bed and reads one book after another after another. He also discusses
Richard III with anyone who enters his hospital room. (His nurses don't
find Richard III as fascinating as Grant does.) For readers who do
enjoy history, historical fiction, this one can prove satisfying. There
is a chance that mystery lovers may enjoy this one too, after all Grant
himself HATES history or hates reading history, but, it may not be for
everyone.
And this SONG is a must!!!!
You might also be interested in: The White Queen by Philippa Gregory, The Tudor Rose: A Novel of Elizabeth of York by Margaret Campbell Barnes, Richard III by William Shakespeare, The Stolen Crown by Susan Higginbotham, Sent by Margaret Peterson Haddix. Rose of York: Love & War by Sandra Worth. The Sunne in Splendour by Sharon Kay Penman. The Kingmaker's Daughter by Philippa Gregory. The Red Queen by Phillipa Gregory. The Lady of the Rivers by Philippa Gregory.
© 2012 Becky Laney of Becky's Book Reviews
4 comments:
I like the premise of this book: a bedridden investigator. Richard III is a rich "character" living in (and creating) a lasting mythology for modern readers.
I have been meaning to read this book for ages, but hasn't happened...
Daughter of TIme is one of my favorite "history mysteries." So, Becky, what's your opinion on the deaths of the two princes after having read all these books on the subject. I know they're mostly fiction, but each one does lay out a scenario for what might have happened to those two boys. I personally find Tey/Grant's theory compelling, but it may be because I liked her book a lot and it was the first one I ever read about the subject.
This has been on my TRB list for ages. Maybe in 2013...
Post a Comment